Monday, November 24, 2008
Sedition Act
1) In your own words, explain why three of the Congressmen were in favor of the Sedition Act, and three were against it; 2) Who was right, the proponents of the Sedition Act or the opponents? Explain your answer; 3) Which political party seemed to support the Sedition Act? Which political party opposed it?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
78 comments:
P2 Mayra A. and Beatriz A.
1. Claiborne said if things are lies, no one will care, if they are true, they should be published. (against)
2. Nicholas said that they can't pass the law because it is not in the constitution. (against)
3. Otis said that is not right to talk about the government so they should pass the law. (for)
4. Dana said that liers would lie and not tell the truth of what they say. (for)
5. Harper said that they should pass it because nobody has a reason to talk about the government. (for)
6. Gallatin said talking about the government doesn't really matter and if you have something to say just say and don't be afraid. (against)
p2.kevin s.
1. Claiborne said if things are lies, no one will care,if they are true,they should be published (against),Nicholas congress in the constitution for authority to pass a bill like the present(against),Otis the guardians of that constitution are bond to provide he was(for it),Dana
p2 Norma Serrano.
1. Claiborne said if things re lies,no one will care,if they re true they should be published. (against). Nicholas found a prohibition against it. (against) Otis said that we should through people in jail if they talk bad about the constitution or the goverment. (for)
p2valeriac andcarlosc
1. Claiborne said if things are lies, no one will care, if they are true,they should be published (against).
2. Nicholas said they can't pass the law because it is not in the Constitution(against).
3. Otis said that it is not right to talk about the government (for it).
4. Dana said that liers would lie and not tell the truth of what they say (for it).
5. Harper said they should pass it because nobody has reasons to talk about the government (for it).
6. Gallatin said they are against it.
P2:AJ,RJ
1. Claiborne said if things are lies,no one will care,if they are true,they should be published.{against}
2. Nicholas said the house of representatives should not have power about passing a law and congress should decide.(against)
3. Otis said that if they can talk about the government they will thing that they can do what ever they want.(for it)
4. Dana said honest man would not lie {for it}
p2 Michael Estrada Madeline Castro :)
-claiborne said that if things are lies,no one will care if they are true,they should be published(AGAINST).
-John nicholas said it was not in the power of he house of representatives to act on th subject.(FOR IT)
- mr. Otis he thought that this law would stop riots and oher form of destruction.(FOR IT)
-MR.Samuel Dana said no good people would want bad things being said about the goverment.(FOR IT)
-Mr.Robert Harper said that before that they didnt have this law so it ws unneccessary to have it now.
(AGAINST IT)
-Mr. Albert Gallatian said that the best weapon is the truth(AGINST)
P.2 Orlando G. & Gonzalo I.
1) Claiborn said if things are lies,no one will care, if they are true they should be publish.(against)
2)the House of Representatives has no power to pass any law as congress can't etheir.(against)
3)
p2. Yaritza Ramirez
-Claiborne said if things are lies no one will care if they are true they should be published. He was against.
-The house of representatives doesn't have the power to act upon or against the sedition act.
-he was for the sedition act because he said that the congress would do anything to protect the constitution so they would keep away the criminal acts the riots and the intimidation of government officers so they would pass that act which would be it a crime to criticize the government.
P2 Estrella M
1.Claiborne said if things are lies,no one will care,if they are true,they will be published.(against it)
2. Nicholas said that the house of representatives should not act on the subject and he sees vain in the powers given to the congress.(against)
3. Otis said that criminal acts like intimidate officers,or riots are acts that will lead to destruction of the constitution and no guardians will provide to against it.(not against)
4. Dana said that no honest man wants the liberty to not say the truth and that this law will work against other publications.(not against)
5. Harper said before that the United States had a gov. they wouldnt never had this law and what kind of change couldve made this to happen and before they were at peace and now they are being driven into war with France.(against)
6. Gallatin said that the truth would combat error
P2. Giselle L. & Areli L.
1.)Claiborne said if things are lies, no one will care, if they are true, they should be published (against)
2.)Nicholas said that within the power of congress in the constitution prohibited against passing it. (against)
3.)Otis said that probably the people would turn against it and they would start saying stuff about the president, congress, and etc. (for it)
4.)Dana said that
5.)Harper
6.)
Andrew G.& LORENA.G
1)mr THOMAS Clairbone WAS AGAINST THE SEDATION ACTS because if things are lies,no one will care,if they are true,they should be published.
2)MR.JHON NICHOLAS was against the sedition acts Because he didn't have the power to pass the bill.
3)mr harrison was for cuase he thought people who talked about the sedition act should be punished.
4)he was for the sedition act because he didnt like to critisize people.
5)
P2. Karla P. Guadalupe M.
1.Claibornesaid if things are lies,no on will care,if they are true,they should be published (against)
Nicholas thought that the House of Representatives should not act on the subject and thought that it should be forbidden.
Harrison thought that the government should protect himself from other people who are saying bad stuff about him. (for)
Samuel thought that peoplewho are real shouldnt mke lies about the government (for)
p2 connie garcia
1. If people are saying things about you then the government should do something about it.
Thomas Claiborne was against it
it was a good idea but he should've done something
P.2 Helen R. and Joseph G.
1. Claiborne said if things are lies, no one will care, if they are true, they should be published. (against)
2. Nicholas said he doesn't have the power to act on the sedition act.(against)
3. Otis is for the sedition acts because he wants to protect the congress from the criminal acts, intimidating the officers, and riots.(for)
4. Dana said that no honest man would be lying ....
P2 Adrian R.
1) Claiborne said if things are lies, no one will care,if they are trve, the should b published(against).
2)Ncholas said can not be pass by the consautuion(Against).
3)otis said that it can be be tend directly to the destruction constitution.
P2. Diana R. Marisssa R.
1.Thomas Claiborne said if things are lies, no one will care,if they are true, they should be published(against)
2.John Nicholas tried to find things that supported the sedition act but instead of finding things that would support it he found things that went against the sedition act, he also said that that the congress can not pass laws and he even checked the counstitution & it was not allowed.(against)
3. Harrison Otis said that the counsitiution was affected by all the riots & criminal acts and that the gaurdians are bond to provide against them.(for)
P2 Javier G.
1)Mr.thomas Claiborne is against the sedition because he did not care what people thought,
2)He did not have the power to pass the bill.
3)He was four the sedition because they should throw people in jail if they talk ad about the sedition
4)He was four it because he did not talk bad things about people.
5)
Pr.2Tania Pelayo & Hiedi Quinonez
1.Claiborne said if things are lies, no one will care, if they are true, they should be published. (angainst)
2. Nicholas said that the house of repersentiteve didn't have all the power to pass the bill. (against)
3.Otis said that the govenment should be able to protect themselfes from other people who are saying bad stuff of them. (for it)
4.Dana said people who are real patriots shouldn't make up lies about their goverment. (for it)
5. Harper said that america could prosper without this act. (against)
P2. Diana R. Marisssa R.
1.Thomas Claiborne said if things are lies, no one will care,if they are true, they should be published(against)
2.John Nicholas tried to find things that supported the sedition act but instead of finding things that would support it he found things that went against the sedition act, he also said that that the congress can not pass laws and he even checked the counstitution & it was not allowed.(against)
3. Harrison Otis said that the counsitiution was affected by all the riots & criminal acts and that the gaurdians are bond to provide against them.(for)
p.3Marcos g.
mr.thomas claiborne
no one cares about lies but if it is true it should be published.
mr.john nicholas
congres has no power to pass that law(angainst)
mr.harisson otis
otis said people are breaking laws rioting and threatening us, and congress should pass a law angains it (for it)
Mr.samual dana
only people who should worry about the sedition act are liars .
Mr.robert harper
the bill is important now because they might be driven to war.
p.3Marcos g.
mr.thomas claiborne
no one cares about lies but if it is true it should be published.
mr.john nicholas
congres has no power to pass that law(angainst)
mr.harisson otis
otis said people are breaking laws rioting and threatening us, and congress should pass a law angains it (for it)
Mr.samual dana
only people who should worry about the sedition act are liars .
Mr.robert harper
the bill is important now because they might be driven to war.
P3 Sara R. Juan G.
1. Claiborne said :"No one cares about Lies,but if it is true, it
2. Nicholas said"Congress has no power to pass that law (AGAINST)
3 Otis said"People are breaking laws,rioting and threathing US, and congress should pass a law against them (foo)
4. Dana said the only people who should worry about the Sedition Act are people who are LIARS.
5. Harper said the bill is important now because
p.3Marcos g.
mr.thomas claiborne
no one cares about lies but if it is true it should be published.
mr.john nicholas
congres has no power to pass that law(angainst)
mr.harisson otis
otis said people are breaking laws rioting and threatening us, and congress should pass a law angains it (for it)
Mr.samual dana
only people who should worry about the sedition act are liars .
Mr.robert harper
the bill is important now because they might be driven to war.
p.3Marcos g.
mr.thomas claiborne
no one cares about lies but if it is true it should be published.
mr.john nicholas
congres has no power to pass that law(angainst)
mr.harisson otis
otis said people are breaking laws rioting and threatening us, and congress should pass a law angains it (for it)
Mr.samual dana
only people who should worry about the sedition act are liars .
Mr.robert harper
the bill is important now because they might be driven to war.
P.3 TaNya .G. and KeViN .G.
#1. Clairborn said no one cares about lies but if it is true,it should be written. (AGAINST)
#2.Nochols said congress has no power to pass that law. (AGAINST)
#3.Otis said people are braking laws,rioting and threatining US,and congress should pass a law against them. (FOR)
#4.Dana said the only people who should worry about the Sedition act are people who liars.
#5.Harper said this bill is important now because on the point of being driven into a war with France.
p3 eliseo r, henry p
1.No one cares about lies but if it is true ,it should be written.(Against).
2.Nicolas said congress has no power to pass that law.
(Against).
3.Otis said people are breaking laws,rioting and threatening us,and congress should pass a law against them.(For).
4.Dana said the only people who should worry about the sedition act are people who are liars.(For).
5.Harper said this bill is important now because we are at war.
p.3
Vanessa F. & jackie.t
1.) Thomas Clairborne- said no one cares about lies- but if it is true, it should be writen (against)
2.) John Nicholas-says congress has no power to pass that law (against)
3.) Harrison Otis-said people are breaking laws, rioting and threatening us, and congress should pass a law against them (for)
4.)Samuel Dana-said the only people who should worry about the sedition act are people who are liars (for)
5.)Robert Harper-this bill is important now because
P3. lizette .g
claiborn - said no one cares baout lies but f it is true, it should be wrtten. (AGAINST)
john nicholas- said congress has no power to pass that law (AGAINST)
Harrison otis - said people are breaking laws rioting and threateing us,
SAMUEL Dana - said the only people who should worry about the Sedition act are peope who are liar (FOR)
ROBERT HARPER - SAID this bil is important now because
p.3 ashly b damian g
1. That no one really cares about lies they only care about the truth the truth should be written or printed. (against)
2. Congress does not have that power to pass the laws (aganst).
3.To many people are breaking laws,rioting and threatining the police ,the congress should pass a law against them (for )
4.the only people should worry about the sedition act are peopl who are liars.
5.this bill is important now becausethey were in peace and now are on the point of being driven into war.
P3 Carlos F. Clairborn said no one cares about lies but if it is true, it should be written. (against)
Nicholas said that congress has no power to pass that law. (against)
Otis said people are breaking laws, rioting and threatening us, and congress should pass a law against them. (for)
Dana said the only people who should worry about the sedition act are people who are liars. (for)
Harper said this bill is important now because that we shouldn't pass it because before we use to have peace and now we have war with France. (against)
Noe. m michael.d
p.3
Clarborn said that no one cares about the lies
.Nichols had said no power to pass that law.
3.otis said that conress they should pass the law.
4.dana said the only people who should worry about the sedition act people who are liar.
5. harper said that the bill is important now because there is government.
p.3 Leo,&laura torres toledo
no ones cares about lies but if it true it should be
written. [against]
nichols said congress has no power to to pass that law.
[against]
otis said people are breaking laws rioting and threatening
us and congress should pass a law against them.[for]
Dana said the only people who should worry about the
sedition act are peaple who are liares[for]
harper said this bill is important because:what change
ha know tacken place to [mack] such a law nessasary...
p.3 Leo,&laura torres toledo
no ones cares about lies but if it true it should be
written. [against]
nichols said congress has no power to to pass that law.
[against]
otis said people are breaking laws rioting and threatening
us and congress should pass a law against them.[for]
Dana said the only people who should worry about the
sedition act are peaple who are liares[for]
harper said this bill is important because:what change
ha know tacken place to [mack] such a law nessasary...
p3 Abigail F.,Noe L.
Clairbon said no one cares about lies-but if it is true,it should be written. (against)
Nicholas said congress has no power to pass that law. (against)
Otis said people are breaking laws rioting and threatening us Congress should pass a law against them. (for)
Dana said the only people who should worry about the Sedition Act are people who are liars.(for)
Harper said this bill is important now because had existed and prosperdwithout the laws.
brandon and saen otis said people are breaking laws rioting and threatining us and congress should pass a law against them. dana said people who should worry about the sedition act are.people who liars.harper said this bill is imporant now beacause.
per.4 Jonathan G & Jesus H
1.If people lie no one cares,but the truth should be published.(against)
2.John Nicholas can't do anything about it,but he found out that this bill can't be passed.(against)
3.Harrison Otis says that the bill should be passed,so people can not say bad things about the government.(for)
4.Samuel Dana says that people shouldn't utter lies about other people.(for)
5.Robert Harper says that before the bill was passed the country was at peace now they could go to war with france.(against)
6.Albert Gallatin says that the best thing to go against lies are to tell the truth.(for)
Bonus Question:Demecratic-Republican Party was against the sedition acts.( Tomas Claiborne,John Nicholes,and Robert Harper)The Federalists Party favors the sedition acts.(Harrison Otis,Samuel Dana,and Albert Gallatin)
P4 Nadia M.
Claiborn said if people lie, no none cares ; but the truth should be published . (Against)
Nicholas said that the House does not have the power to work on whethier the bill should be passed or not . (Against)
Otis said criminal acts and riots were not part of the constituition people who were for the constitution cant be held responsible. (For)
Dana said that no one who is honest is going to want others to be able to have the rights to lie and that if the bill passes it would give them this right . (Against)
Harper said that before this law everything was peaceful and okay and now that something is wrong and now this law is necessary. and now it is driving us into a war with France. (Against)
Gallatin said if we need to punish for what they write/publish , then we cant defend their rights . (Against)
P4 Marcos C. & Ariana C.
Claiborne is said if people lie no ones cares; but the truth should be published.(against)
Nicholas said the house of representatives didnt have the power to do anything. (against)
Otis said that the guardians of the constitution a.k.a the congress should be able to create laws that would protect it from destruction. (for)
Dana said A man doesn't want to lie but this act wouldn't let them tell the truth.(for)
Harper said that before this law was made everything was peaceful and okay and now something went wrong that this law is now necessary,which is also now driving us into a war with France.(against)
Gallatin said that if we need to punish people for what they write/publish, then we can't defend their rights. (against)
P4. Crystal C. & Juan C.
1.Claiborne said if eople lie, no one cares; but the truth should be published.(against)
- Nicholas said that if he confesses ten he impresses himself but that confessing is not in th powes f the hos of representatives he doesnt like the way the cogress in the constitution have the powr to pass bills but he is against it. (against)
-.Otis said that criminal acts on te government are part of the destruction to the constitution and there is no doubt that people are against them.(for)
-Dana said that no hnest man would want to not say the truth and this law will be no other publications.(for)
- Harper said that before this Tthe government was at peace and wht changes made thm make a law like this it ws that the governmet was no longer in peace (for)
-Gallatin said you cannot defend peopl with writing only weapons .(against)
2.We think the proponents because
P4 Leovardo G. & Christopher H.
Claiborne said if the people lie, no one cares; but the truth should be published. (against)
Nicholas said the power of the house of representative should not give the power of the consitution to the authority to pass such a law.(against)
Otis said that we needed officers to stop criminal acts to oppose measurements of goverment. (against)
Dana said If you can't say the truth about someone don't say nothing at all.(against)
Harper said gentlemen who oppose the law are saying whats the point of a bill if they pass the law and the goverment vetos it.(for)
Gallatin said that the truth is our important weapon.(for)
P4 Samantha R
1.Clairborne- if people lie, who cares; but the truth should be published. (against)
Nicholas-that the house of representatives doesnt have the power to react to the bill.(against)
Otis- that it is bad to intimidate officers, start riots because it tears apart the constitution.(for)
Dana-no honest person wants to lie.(against)
Harper-that gentlemen who fought against the bill said that why is the change neccesary if we were at peace with France.(against)
Gallatin-that the proper weapon to fight error is truth;and to manipulate and go straight into punishment so that we wont let writtings make us say the truth.
4.Which political party supported the Sedition Act?
Which party opposed it?
Otis was for th Sedition act. Claiborne Nicholas Dana Harper and Gallatin were against the Sedition Acts.
p4. Karen C and Benjamin C
* Caliborne said if people lie, no one cares;but the truth should be punished.(against)
*The house of repersentatives didn`t let Nicholas pass the bill he wanted to pass(against)
*Criminal acts and riots were not part of the constitution people who were for the contitution can`t be held responsable(for)
*Not saying the truth about other people can not let prisoners out of jail(for)
P.4 eliseo j. josmar l.
Thomas Clairborne- if people lie no one cares but yhe truth should be published. (against)
John Nicholas- the house does not have the power to work on whetheir the bill should be passed or not. (against)
Harrion Ford- they want to protect the Constitution from criminals so he wants to pass the Sedition Acts. (for)
Samuel Dana-no honest man wants people to lie about the government and this law will prevent it (FOR)
Robert Harper-Before this law was passed we had peace and now we need it because we are in war
(for)
Albert Gallatin-to fix a wrong you have to tell the truth (against)
FEDERALISTS-for
DEMOCRATIC R-against
P.4 Jaime P & Luis R
1. Claiborne said if people lie who cares; but the truth should be published. (against)
2. Nicholas said that Congress shouldn't be able to pass that law because it's not in their authority. (against)
3. Otis said that Congress is getting threatened so they should be able to defend themselves. (for)
4. Dana said if your honest you shouldn't be worried. This law is for people who lie. (for)
5. Harper said without this law country would go to war with France. (for)
6. Gallatin said that people have rights. Congress can't force you to not talk about the government. (against)
Antonio B. Cecilia A.
p.4
Claiborne said if people lie, no one cares; but the truth should be published. (against)
Nicholas believed that the House of Representatives did not have the power to do anything about it. Congress of the Constitution could not pass it. (against)
Otis says that if people are riotig and intimidating policemen, a law should be made against it. (for)
Dana no truthful man would like the the liberty of not saying the truth. If your honest, you don't have to worry about the law. Liers should be scared. (for)
Harpar says that we should not say anything against the president. Instead we should talk about the other country, terrorist, and our enemies. (against)
Gallatin the best weapon is the truth. If we start punishing people for what they say, we can't defend ourselfs. (against)
P4 Raymundo R. & Osbaldo V p4.
-1.Claiborne said: if people lie, no one cares;but the truth should be published. (against)
-2. Nicholas said: that the House of Rep doesn't have the power to react to it. (against)
-3. Harrison said: that if it passes it would lead to the destruction of the Constituiton. (for it)
-4. Dana said: no man wantsto be lied to by the gov and this law would do that. (against)
-5. Harper said: That it should pass because we are about to go to war with France. (for it)
-6. Gallatin said: That words are stronger than weponds. (for it)
Antonio B. Cecilia A.
p.4
Claiborne said if people lie, no one cares; but the truth should be published. (against)
Nicholas believed that the House of Representatives did not have the power to do anything about it. Congress of the Constitution could not pass it. (against)
Otis says that if people are riotig and intimidating policemen, a law should be made against it. (for)
Dana no truthful man would like the the liberty of not saying the truth. If your honest, you don't have to worry about the law. Liers should be scared. (for)
Harpar says that we should not say anything against the president. Instead we should talk about the other country, terrorist, and our enemies. (against)
Gallatin the best weapon is the truth. If we start punishing people for what they say, we can't defend ourselfs. (against)
Antonio B. Cecilia A.
p.4
Claiborne said if people lie, no one cares; but the truth should be published. (against)
Nicholas believed that the House of Representatives did not have the power to do anything about it. Congress of the Constitution could not pass it. (against)
Otis says that if people are riotig and intimidating policemen, a law should be made against it. (for)
Dana no truthful man would like the the liberty of not saying the truth. If your honest, you don't have to worry about the law. Liers should be scared. (for)
Harpar says that we should not say anything against the president. Instead we should talk about the other country, terrorist, and our enemies. (against)
Gallatin the best weapon is the truth. If we start punishing people for what they say, we can't defend ourselfs. (against)
Luis C.
Ashley C.
Per. 4
1) Clairborne- Clairborne said if people lie no one cares; but the truth should be published. (against)
Nicholas- Nicholas said the House of Reps. do not have the power to act on the subject. (against)
Otis- Without the use of this law, police officers would be scared, riots would explode, which would lead towards the downfall of the constitution. (for)
Dana- He doesn't want people to make up false e office statements & this law would help prevent that. (for)
Harper- The government of the US has thrived without making a law of this kind in the past. This law is necessary because they are at war. (for)
Gallatin- to persuade using threats and punishments, to silence people isn't protecting their rights. (against)
E.C. 4) The Federalists supported Sedition Acts and Democratic-Republicans opposed of it.
Luis C.
Ashley C.
Per. 4
1) Clairborne- Clairborne said if people lie no one cares; but the truth should be published. (against)
Nicholas- Nicholas said the House of Reps. do not have the power to act on the subject. (against)
Otis- Without the use of this law, police officers would be scared, riots would explode, which would lead towards the downfall of the constitution. (for)
Dana- He doesn't want people to make up false e office statements & this law would help prevent that. (for)
Harper- The government of the US has thrived without making a law of this kind in the past. This law is necessary because they are at war. (for)
Gallatin- to persuade using threats and punishments, to silence people isn't protecting their rights. (against)
E.C. 4) The Federalists supported Sedition Acts and Democratic-Republicans opposed of it.
p4. Adonis .A Karina. A
1) Mr. Thomas Claiborne-If people lie no one cares but the truth should be published.(AGAINST)
2) Mr.John Nicholas- He is sayng that the law cannot be passed because it is a law violating the constitution.(AGAINST)
3)Mr. Harrison Otis-He said fight back by making new laws the Sedition law. (FOR)
4) Mr. Samuel Dana- He said it was a god law to take any one to criticize the government to be sent to jail and the only people who have to worry about it this law are those people that critizice.
5) Mr. Robert Harper-He is saying that not to critizice the president critizice the people we are al against which are the French.(AGAINST)
6)Albert Gallatin-the law woif we start punishing people for what they say we cant defend that but that is what we are supposed to do.(AGAINST)
P.4 Maribel Diaz, Adrian Cuadras
1. Mr. Thomas Claiborne said if people lie, no one cares; but the truth should be published.[against]
2. Mr. John Nicholas said that he checked on the Constitution and it says that its forbidden to pass this law.[against]
3. Mr. Harrison Otis doesn't want a riot of the people of their lies and he isn't going to just sit there he's going to make a low. [for]
4.Mr. Samuel Dana said the low will only affect the peole how like to lie and get mad if their not aloud to lie. People will only get punished if you lie, so don't lie. If you don't lie then don't worry about it. [for]
5.
6. Mr. Albert Gallation said to defend our self we need the truth. we to yous our words or it will be hopless. [agenst]
*
P.4 Jazmine G. & Lizbeth D.
1.Claiborne said if people lie, but hte truth should be published. (against)
2. Nicholas said that a congress cant pass the law of sedition acts because its not in the list that congress could pass. (against)
3. Otis said that if you theaten the goverment in any way the Constitution would fight back by making a law had trowing you in jail. (for)
Dana said that any lair want to pass the law of lieing because only liars would want to lie. (for)
Harper said that people should not critisis the government to critisis the french(one for all and all for one).(against)
Gallatin said that why do we need punishments now with weapons and not back then. (for)
p4 Jeffrey M.
1.Claiborne said if people lie no one cares; but the truth should be published.(Against)
2.Nicholas said that the House doesn't have the power to act on this subject but that the Congress in the constitution has the power forbid the law.(Against)
3.Otis said because people are destroying the Constitution,making riots, and doing criminal acts they should pass the sedition act to make them be quiet.(For)
4.Dana said that they should pass it because only liars would.(For)
5.Harper said before this law everything was peaceful and now there is war with France because of this law.(Against)
6.Gallatin said if true than its true but if its false than forget about it. (for)
P4 Chantal M & Hector M.
1. Claiborne said if people lie, no one cares; but the truth should be published. (Against).
2. Nicholas felt that they couldn't pass the act because the Constitution didn't give them the authority to do it. (Against).
3. Otis thought that they should defend themselves by passing laws. (For).
4. Dana thought that honest people shouldn't worry about the sedition acts because their not guilty.(For)
5. Harper believe that they only needed Constitution when at peace but now they are at war with France(for).
6.Gallatin thought that
5.
p.5 brandO A. and miguel R.
1.thomas said no one realy cared if lies were told, bt if they are true, they should be published.(against)
2. Nicholas said congress didnt havehe has looked in vain with the powers of the consatution.
3.otis said that people were brakingthe laws, and rioing, so the government needed to protect aginst them.
4.dana said that people who tell the truth should be rewarde for telling the truh.
5.harper said that the reason the sedition act was needed who was 'what change has now taken place to make such a law neccessary'.
6.gallatin said the best way to prove we are right is to say we have the proper wepon for combat.
p.5 brandO A. and miguel R.
1.thomas said no one realy cared if lies were told, bt if they are true, they should be published.(against)
2. Nicholas said congress didnt havehe has looked in vain with the powers of the consatution.
3.otis said that people were brakingthe laws, and rioing, so the government needed to protect aginst them.
4.dana said that people who tell the truth should be rewarde for telling the truh.
5.harper said that the reason the sedition act was needed who was 'what change has now taken place to make such a law neccessary'.
6.gallatin said the best way to prove we are right is to say we have the proper wepon for combat.
p.5 brandO A. and miguel R.
1.thomas said no one realy cared if lies were told, bt if they are true, they should be published.(against)
2. Nicholas said congress didnt havehe has looked in vain with the powers of the consatution.
3.otis said that people were brakingthe laws, and rioing, so the government needed to protect aginst them.
4.dana said that people who tell the truth should be rewarde for telling the truh.
5.harper said that the reason the sedition act was needed who was 'what change has now taken place to make such a law neccessary'.
6.gallatin said the best way to prove we are right is to say we have the proper wepon for combat.
p5. James S. & Leo H.
1. Caliborne said no one cared of lies were told but if they are true, the should be published
2. Nicholas said Congress didn't have te power to pass some laws.
3. Otis said that people were breaking laws,an rioting,so the goverment needed to stop the rioting and breaking laws.
GISELLE G.
P.5
1.Claiborne said "NO ONE CARED IF HE LIES WERE TOLD, BUT IF THEY ARE TRUE, THEY SHOULD BE PUBLISHED" {AGAINST}
2. NICHOLAS said "CONGRESS DIDNT HAVE TO
PASS ALL THE LAWS THAT THEY WE GIVEN"[AGAINST]
3.OTIS said'' THAT PEOPLE WERE BRAKING LAWS AND RIGHTS,SO THE GOVERNMENT NEEDED TO GET STRONGER AND INFOCE THE LAWS MORE"[FOR IT]
4.DANA said''THAT THE PEOPLE WHO TELL THE TRUTH SHOULD BE AWARDED "[FOR IT]
5. HARPER said "THAT THE REASON THE SEDITION ACT WAS NEEDED NOW WAS KEEP USE OUT OF WAR"[FOR IT]
6. GALLATIN said"THE BEST WAY TO PORVE WE ARE RIGHT IS TO SAY THE TRUTH"[AGAINST]
p5 Jorge & Robert
Claiborne said,
no one cred if lies were told, but if they are true, they should be published. (against)
Nicholas said,
That congress doesn't have the power to do that.(against)
Gallatin said,
Harrison said,
That in order to take care of the constiitution it had to be pass.(Fore)
Ms. Dana said,
That people how say the truth don't have to worry about this.(Fore)
salvador alejandre p.5
but if they are true,they should be published.
2.John Nicholas was against it because the house of Representitive was to weak to pass.
3.Harrison Otis is for because of all the writing and intimedating oficcers.
4.Samuel Dana was for because an honest person wouldn't wan't to tell a lie.
5.Robert Harper was for it because the act was needed now.
p5 Jorge & Robert
Claiborne said,
no one cred if lies were told, but if they are true, they should be published. (against)
Nicholas said,
That congress doesn't have the power to do that.(against)
Gallatin said,
Harrison said,
That in order to take care of the constiitution it had to be pass.(Fore)
Ms. Dana said,
That people how say the truth don't have to worry about this.(Fore)
p5 Jorge & Robert
Claiborne said,
no one cred if lies were told, but if they are true, they should be published. (against)
Nicholas said,
That congress doesn't have the power to do that.(against)
Gallatin said,
Harrison said,
That in order to take care of the constiitution it had to be pass.(Fore)
Ms. Dana said,
That people how say the truth don't have to worry about this.(Fore)
p5 Jorge & Robert
Claiborne said,
no one cred if lies were told, but if they are true, they should be published. (against)
Nicholas said,
That congress doesn't have the power to do that.(against)
Gallatin said,
Harrison said,
That in order to take care of the constiitution it had to be pass.(Fore)
Ms. Dana said,
That people how say the truth don't have to worry about this.(Fore)
p.5 Denise G. Rosalina L.
Claiborne-no one cared if they are true,they should be published (aganist)
Nicholas-congress did'nt have enough of power for publishing the bill (aganist)
Otis-people were braking and riting,so the goverment needid to protect the goverment and the constitution (aganist)
Dana-peopel who tell the truth you have nothing to worry about(for)
p.5 Selena E. Estefania G.
1.The speaker was against the sedition act.
2.Nicolas said Congress didn't have authority to pass the bill because its not the list of laws they could pass.
Nicolas is against sedition act.
3.otis stated that people are breaking laws and rioting the goverment needed to protect the constitntion. Otis is for the sedition act.
5.
p.5 sabrina g. and leslie q.
1.) Claiborne said no one cared if lies were told, but if they are true ,they should be published. (against)
2.)Nicholas said Congress dosnt have the power as the house of the representitive and the cenet.(against)
3.)Otis said that people were breaking lows, and rioting, so the government needed to
Sergio G. & Humberto G.
p.5
1.Thomas Claiborne said theres no harm done if a lie is told but if it be the truth it should be told (against)
2. John Nicholas said congress didn't have the authority to pas that law because it is not on their list of things comgrees can do.(against)
3. Harisson Otis said it is congress' job to protect the constitution therefore we should do whatever it takes to protect it.(for)
4. Samuel Dana said no honest wants liberty where you can't tell the truth.(against)
5.Robert Harper said people say that we have lived without any law of this kind before what change has taken place so that we need it now, in my opinion back then we were in peace now we are at the peak of getting into a war with France.(for)
6. Albert Gallatin said the truth is the right weapon in combat error and to take that away could not be defended in any way
p.5 jacob D. Suejey G.
Mr.thomas claiborne said no one cared if lies were told but if they are true they should be published.
(against)
MR.John Nicholas said that congress didnt have the power to pass it.(against)
Mr.Harrison Otis said that people were breaking laws and rioting so the goverment needed to pass sedition act.(for)
MR.SamuelDana said that people who tell the truth wont want to tell lies(for)
MR.Robert Harper said that the reason the sedition act was needed now was because the U.S. was at te point of going to war.
p.5 Fatima J. G.
Clairborne said no one cared if lies were told, but if they are true , they should be published (against)
Nicholas said Congress didnt have enough power to pass the Bill.
Otis said that people were breakng laws, rioting, so the governmment needed to lead to destruct the Constitution.
Dana said that people who tell the truth dont hav to worry about anything, if you lie you might have to suffer the consequences.
P5.JAVIER.M
1)Claiborne said no one caedif lies weretold,but if they are true they should be publishd (against)
2)Nicholas said congress did't have enough power for publishing the bill(against)
3)otis said that people were breaking laws, and rioting ,so the goverment needed to protect the goverment and the consitution (against)
4)dana said that people who tell the truth you dont have to worry about anything if you tell a lie you go to jail(for)
5)harper said that the reason the sediction act
P5. Kimberly L. & Valery O.
#1) Claiborne said no cared if lies were told,
but if they are true, they should be publised. [against]
#2)Nicholas said congress didn't have
the power to pass unconstitutional laws.(against)
#3)Otis said that people were breaking laws, and rioting, so the government needed to try to stop
them because its leading to distruction to the
constition. The guardians are bound to provide
them.
josephine&estephanie p.5
1.claibrone said no one cared if lies were told but ir truth told,then it should be publishd.[against it]
2.nicholas said congress didnt have the powers to act on this subject&are forbidden to.[against it]
3.otis said that people were breaking laws,and rioting,so th government needed to make that law to protect the constitution.[for it]
4.dana said that people who tell the truth dont want lies to be published.[for it]
5.harpet said that the reason the sedition act was needed now was because to stay out of war.[for it]
6.gallatin said the best way to prove we r right is to write the truth [against it]
p.5 Jonathan R. & Beatriz G.
1. Claiborne said, no one cared if lies were told,but if there are true they should be punished. (against)
2. Nicholas said, congress didn't have the power to pass any sedition laws. (against)
3. Otis said that people were breaking laws,and rioting, so the government needed to
4. Dana said that the people who tell the truth have the all the liberty they want to have.
5. Harper said that the reason the sedition act was needed now was
p.5 Jonathan R. & Beatriz G.
1. Claiborne said, no one cared if lies were told,but if there are true they should be punished. (against)
2. Nicholas said, congress didn't have the power to pass any sedition laws. (against)
3. Otis said that people were breaking laws,and rioting, so the government needed to
4. Dana said that the people who tell the truth have the all the liberty they want to have.
5. Harper said that the reason the sedition act was needed now was
P:5 CINDY V. & ROBERTO U.
1.) Claiborne said no one cared if lies were told,but if they are true,they should be published. (against)
2.) Nicholas said congress didn't have authority to pass a bill like the present. (against)
3.)Otis said that people wre breaking laws,and rioting,so the goverment needed to add more protection. (against)
4.) Dana said that people who tell the truth live better.(against)
5.) Harper said that the reason the Sedition Act was needed now was
6.) Gallatin said the best way to prove we are right is to say
P5. Brian S. and Chris Caliborne said no one cared if lies were told, but if they should be published (against)
Nicholas said congress didn't have the authority to pass a bill like this one. (against)
Otis said that unlawful destruction hurts the constitution and that we need to find more guardians to protect the constitution.(against)
Post a Comment